Proving Federal Crimes

Table of Contents

Chapter 1                  Structuring the Investigation                 

1.01    Overview

1.02    Analyzing the initial complaint

1.03    Authority of agent to act

1.04    Preliminary inquiries

1.05    Legality of investigative techniques

1.06    Aiding and Abetting

1.07    Conspiracy

1.08    Crime scene

1.09    Evidence response teams

1.10    Financial investigations

1.11    FinCEN

1.12    Tax records

1.13    Asset forfeiture

1.14    Pre-seizure planning

1.15    Digital evidence

1.16    Cellular phones

1.17    Tracing e-mail

1.18    Smart cards

1.19    DNA

1.20    Mail covers

1.21    Parallel proceedings

1.22    Report writing and maintaining notes

1.23    Witness interviews and interrogations

1.24    Responsibilities toward victims and witnesses

1.25    Child witnesses and victims

1.26    Material witnesses

1.27    The use of pseudonyms by witnesses

1.28    Law of arrest

1.29    Lineups and showups

1.30    Power to order lineup

1.31    Lineup -- self-incrimination

1.32    Lineup -- search and seizure

1.33    Admissibility of lineup and showup

1.34    Physical evidence

1.35    Gunshot residue evidence

1.36    Trace evidence -- hairs/fibers -- crime scene

1.37    Surgical instructions and blood samples

1.38    fingerprinting

1.39    Handwriting exemplars

1.40    Voice exemplars

1.41    Spectrographs -- voice print

1.42    Polygraphs

1.43    Hypnosis

1.44    Hypnosis of a defendant

1.45    Disclosure of the use of hypnosis

1.46    Hypnosis – factors to consider

1.47    Computer animations

1.48    Subpoenas to attorneys

1.49    Identity theft

1.50    The USA Patriot Act

1.51    National security

1.52    Classified information

1.53    Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA)

Chapter 2                  Search Warrants

2.01    Use of search warrants

2.02         Probable cause for search warrant

2.03         Timeliness of information

2.04         Probable cause establish by hearsay

2.05         False statement in affidavit

2.06         Particularity of a description

2.07         Time of warrant

2.08         Who may execute warrant

2.09         Knock and announce

2.10         Plain view and other seizure rules

2.11         Good Faith

2.12         Anticipatory warrants

2.13         Sneak and peek warrants – USA Patriot Act § 213

2.14         Body Instructions

2.15         Computers

2.16         Administrative search warrants

2.17         Execution and return with inventory

2.18         Return of seized property

2.19         Search warrant return form

2.20         Constructing affidavit – sample language

2.21         Affidavit – documents

2.22         Affidavit – identification documents

2.23         Search warrant form

Chapter 3                  Warrantless Searches

3.01         Warrantless searches

3.02         Non searches

3.03         Consent searches

3.04         Border and customs searches

3.05         Sea searches

3.06         Expectation of privacy/standing

3.07         Search incident to valid arrest

3.08         Validity of the arrest

3.09         When a person is under arrest

3.10         Search must be contemporaneous with arrest

3.11         Scope of Warrantless searches incident to arrest

3.12         Seizures without probable cause

3.13         Stop and frisk

3.14         Detention of occupants during search

3.15         Exigent circumstances

3.16         Emergencies

3.17         Destruction, removal or escape

3.18         Hot pursuit

3.19         Vehicle searches

3.20         Inventory searches of vehicles

3.21         Evidence in plain view

3.22         Prison searches

3.23         Administrative searches

3.24         The exclusionary rule

3.25         Fruit of Poisonous Tree

3.26         Inevitable discovery

3.27         Independent source

3.28         Attenuation

3.29         Other rules affecting admissibility

3.30         Motions to suppress

3.31         Hearing issues

3.32         Appeals

Chapter 4                  Electronic Surveillance

4.01         Overview

4.02         History of legislation

4.03         Patriot Act amendments

4.04         The authorization request

4.05         Roving interception

4.06         Emergency interception

4.07         Video surveillance -- approval required

4.08         Use of Title III affidavits

4.09         Consensual monitoring

4.10         Consensual monitoring – DOJ procedures

4.11         Overhears – discovery

4.12         Overhears – attorneys

4.13         Title III applications

4.14         Title III affidavits

4.15         Title III orders

4.16         Managing the wiretap

4.17         Post-interception requirements

4.18         Wiretap checklist

4.19         Investigative techniques complementing a wiretap

4.20         Non-disclosure of investigative techniques

4.21         Suppression of Title III evidence

4.22         Other electronic evidence

4.23         Video surveillance

4.24         The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA)

4.25         The Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA)

Chapter 5                  International Issues

5.01         Overview

5.02         Diplomatic Immunity

5.03         International legal assistance

5.04         Obtaining evidence abroad

5.05         Statute of limitations and the Speedy Trial Act

5.06         Cost and methods of obtaining evidence

5.07         Letters rogatory

5.08         Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATS)

5.09         Executive agreement

5.10         Informal methods

5.11         The FBI’s Legal Attache program

5.12         Subpoenas

5.13         Forfeiture of foreign assets

5.14         Drafting requests for assistance

5.15         Translations

5.16         Documentary evidence

5.17         Depositions

5.18         Arrest of foreign nationals

5.19         Arrest of foreign territories

Chapter 6                  Fugitives

6.01         Overview

6.02         Preventing fugitivity

6.03         Locating fugitives

6.04         OIA’S fugitive unite

6.05         Fugitive Felon Act (UFAP)

6.06         Interpol

6.07         Fugitive diffusion form

6.08         Form – agreement to extradite

6.09         Foreign extradition

6.10         Procedures for extradition

6.11         Provisional arrest

6.12         Extradition procedure in the foreign country

6.13         Return of the fugitive

6.14         Alternatives to extradition

6.15         U.S. extraditions to foreign nations

6.16         Interstate extradition and the agreement of Detainers

6.17         Transfer to other federal district

Chapter 7                  Admissions and Confessions

7.01         Overview

7.02         Jackson v. Denno hearings

7.03         Foundation questions

7.04         Voluntariness

7.05         Tricks and deceit

7.06         Threats and promises

7.07         Custody definition

7.08         Custody – place of detention

7.09         Interrogation defined

7.10         Routine booking questions and pre-sentence reports

7.11         Public safety

7.12         Private citizens

7.13         The Miranda warnings -- generally

7.14         Miranda warnings -- asking if the suspect understands the rights

7.15         Miranda warnings -- requesting an explicit waiver

7.16         Waiving Miranda Rights -- generally

7.17         Intelligent waiver

7.18         Voluntary waiver

7.19         Assertion of right to remain silent

7.20         Assertion of right to counsel

7.21         Ambiguous and unambiguous invocations-- Davis and Smith

7.22         Break in custody

7.23         Anticipatory invocations

7.24         Initiation

7.25         The Sixth Amendment right  to counsel

7.26         Sixth Amendment waiver

7.27         Asking for an attorney at arraignment

7.28         Ethical considerations

7.29         Impeachment

7.30         Fruit of illegal searches and seizures

7.31         Illegal detention

7.32         Fruit of an involuntary confession

7.33         Fruit of a Miranda violation -- Elstad

7.34         Miranda and psychiatrists

7.35         Co-defendant confessions the Bruton rule

7.36         Grand jury target warnings

7.37         Sample target letter

7.38         Sample proffer letter

7.39         Model interrogations and confessions policy

7.40         Foreign prosecutions

Chapter 8                  Self-incrimination and Immunity

8.01         Overview

8.02         Self-incrimination at trial

8.03         Grounds for invoking privilege

8.04         Waiver of privilege by witness

8.05         Waiver of privilege by testifying defendant

8.06         Requiring defendant to give non-testimonial evidence

8.07         Invocation by prosecution witness

8.08         Calling witness who will claim privilege

8.09         The privilege after a guilty plea

8.10         Informal/formal immunity distinguished

8.11         Derivative use immunity

8.12         Statutory authority to compel testimony

8.13         Approval and authorization for formal immunity

8.14         Authorization procedure for immunity requests

8.15         Decision to request immunity -- the public interest

8.16         Decision to request immunity -- close-family exception

8.17         Decision to request immunity -- conviction prior to compulsion

8.18         Granting immunity on behalf of a defendant

8.19         Obtaining the court order

8.20         Immunity for the act of production

8.21         Authorization to prosecute after compulsion

8.22         Use of immunized testimony by sentencing court

8.23         Steps to avoid taint

8.24         Civil contempt

8.25         Criminal contempt

Chapter 9                  Informants

9.01         Overview

9.02         DOJ informant guidelines

9.03         Prosecution strategies

9.04         Defense strategies

9.05         Jury instructions

9.06         Cooperation agreements

Chapter 10               Corporations

10.01    Overview

10.02    Corporate criminal liability

10.03    Corporate privilege issues

10.04    Contacts with represented parties

10.05    Indictment

10.06    Charging corporations -- generally

10.07    Charging corporations -- factors

10.08    Special policy concerns

10.09    Pervasiveness of wrongdoing

10.10    Corporate past history

10.11    Cooperation and voluntary disclosure

10.12    Corporate compliance programs

10.13    Restitution and remediation

10.14    Collateral consequences

10.15    Non-criminal alternatives

10.16    Selecting charges

10.17    Plea agreements with corporations

10.18    Taking corporate guilty pleas

10.19    Sarbanes-Oxley

10.20    Federal securities laws

10.21    Corporate bookkeeping practices

10.22    Jury instructions: Corporate responsibility

10.23    Jury instructions: personal responsibility of corporate agent

10.24    Sentencing

10.25    Market capitalization as the measure of loss

10.26    Professional responsibility issues in corporate fraud matters

Chapter 11               Prosecution of Juveniles

11.01    Overview

11.02    Disposition

11.03    Certification

11.04    Certification -- form

11.05    Filing of the complaint

11.06    Motion to transfer

11.07    Arrest of a juvenile

11.08    Interrogation and presentment

11.09    Detention of juveniles

11.10    Parental notification

11.11    Photos and fingerprints

11.12    Publicity

11.13    Prosecutorial discretion

11.14    Child witnesses and victims

11.15    Sample juvenile information

Chapter 12               Grand Jury

12.01    Overview

12.02    Functions, powers and limitations

12.03    Power of grand jury limited

12.04    Venue limitations

12.05    Limitation on naming unindicted co-conspirators

12.06    Limitations of subpoenas

12.07    Fair credit reporting act and grand jury subpoenas

12.08    Subpoenas for financial records

12.09    Subpoenaing targets

12.10    Advice of “rights” to grand jury witnesses

12.11    Request by subjects and targets to testify

12.12    Notification of targets

12.13    Advance assertion of an intention to claim the Fifth Amendment privilege

12.14    Notification to targets when target status end

12.15    Limitation on resubpoenaing contumacious witnesses

12.16    Illegally obtained evidence

12.17    Hearsay

12.18    Exculpatory evidence

12.19    Authorized attorneys

12.20    Presence of an interpreter

12.21    Grand jury secrecy

12.22    Disclosure to DOJ attorneys

12.23    Guidelines for handling grand jury documents

12.24    Subpoenas to lawyers and the news media

12.25    The special grand jury – 18 U.S.C. § 3331

12.26    Intelligence gathering and the grand jury

Chapter 13               Ethical Issues

13.01    Overview

13.02    The role of the federal prosecutor

13.03    The charging decision

13.04    Selective prosecution

13.05    Vindictive prosecution

13.06    Number of charges

13.07    Exculpatory evidence

13.08    Witness preparation

13.09    Opening statement

13.10    False evidence

13.11    Use of plea agreements

13.12    Inflammatory or otherwise inadmissible evidence

13.13    Conduct of testifying agents

13.14    Forcing a claim of privilege

13.15    Use of defendant’s evidence

13.16    Closing arguments

13.17    Invited response doctrine

13.18    Sentencing - grand jury disclosures

Chapter 14               Jurisdiction

14.01    Overview

14.02    Subject matter jurisdiction

14.03    The Commerce Clause

14.04    Extraterritorial jurisdiction

14.05    General maritime jurisdiction

14.06    General maritime offenses

14.07    Piracy

14.08    Violence against maritime navigation

14.09    Hostage taking

14.10    Terrorist acts abroad against U.S. nationals

14.11    Extraterritorial terrorism

14.12    USA Patriot Act

14.13    Conspiracy in the United States to murder, kidnap, maim or damage property overseas

14.14    Territorial jurisdiction

14.15    Assimilative Crimes Act

14.16    Aircraft jurisdiction

14.17    India country

14.18    Property held proprietarily

14.19    Jurisdiction as element

14.20    Personal jurisdiction

14.21    Venue

14.22    Venue – offenses in more than one district

14.23    Venue – Offenses no committed in any district

14.24    Venue for indirect criminal contempt

14.25    Rule 21 transfer of venue

14.26    Venue waiver form

Chapter 15               Indictments

15.01    Overview

15.02    Caption and citation

15.03    Subscription

15.04    Elements

15.05    Culpable mental state

15.06    Bill of particulars

15.07    Date and time

15.08    Jurisdiction and venue

15.09    Amendment and variance

15.10    Conjunctive/disjunctive

15.11    Multiplicity and duplicity

15.12    Conspiracy

15.13    Superseding indictments

15.14    Waiver

Chapter 16               Preliminary Procedures

16.01    Arrest

16.02    Criminal complaints

16.03    Warrant/summons

16.04    First appearance

16.05    Preliminary examinations

16.06    Charting the Speedy Trial clock

16.07    Arraignment

16.08    Rule 12 notices

16.09    Rule 12 pretrial motions

16.10    Rule 15 depositions

16.11    Rule 20 transfers

Chapter 17               Bail & Detention

17.01    General provisions

17.02    Bail reform act

17.03    Categories

17.04    Personal recognizance

17.05    Conditional release

17.06    Eligibility for release - actors

17.07    Temporary detention orders

17.08    Detention

17.09    Bail application following detention

17.10    Breach of condition of bond

17.11    Defendant’s appeal of detention order

17.12    Miscellaneous sections

Chapter 18               Discovery

18.01    Overview

18.02    Statements of defendant

18.03    Defendant’s prior record

18.04    Documents and objects

18.05    Reports of examination and tests

18.06    Expert witnesses

18.07    Witness list

18.08    Witness list of non-testifying people

18.09    Disclosure of identities of informants

18.10    Witness statement

18.11    Witness interviews

18.12    Protective orders

18.13    Disclosure by the defendant

18.14    Information not subject to disclosure

18.15    Continuing duty to disclose

18.16    Sanctions for failure to provide discovery

18.17    Rule 17 © subpoenas

18.18    Notice of defenses

18.19    Bill of particulars

18.20    FOIA

Chapter 19               Brady-Giglio

19.01    Overview

19.02    Brady material

19.03    Materiality

19.04    Doubts to be resolved in favor of disclosure

19.05    Knowing use of false testimony – Napue v. Illinois

19.06    Credibility evidence

19.07    Personnel records

19.08    Court under no duty to research files of prosecutor

19.09    Timing of disclosure of Brady material

19.10    Material available to the prosecution

19.11    CIPA

19.12    Non-prosecution agreements

19.13    Types of information to request

19.14    Consequences of non-disclosure

Chapter 20               Jencks Act

20.01    Overview

20.02    Production of government witness’s statements

20.03    Subject matter testimony

20.04    Trial court review

20.05    Reasonable time to review

20.06    Statements producible under the Jenks Act

20.07    Notes of witness interviews

20.08    Reports by government agents

20.09    Prosecutor’s notes

20.10    Grand jury testimony

20.11    Destruction of interview notes

Chapter 21               Speedy Trial

21.01    Overview

21.02    Constitutional speedy trial protection

21.03    Barker v. Wingo

21.04    Length of delay

21.05    Cause for delay

21.06    Timely assertion of speedy trial right

21.07    Prejudice caused by delay

21.08    The Speedy Trial Act

21.09    Excludable delay

21.10    Ends of justice continuances

21.11    Withdrawn plea

21.12    Incarcerated elsewhere

21.13    Sanctions

21.14    Waiver

21.15    Pre-accusation delay

Chapter 22               Joiner and Severance

22.01    Overview

22.02    Joinder of offenses

22.03    Multiple counts

22.04    Multiple indictments

22.05    Joinder of defendants

22.06    Same indictment

22.07    Consolidation for trial

22.08    Conspiracy

22.09    Relief from prejudicial Joinder

22.10    Severance of offenses

22.11    Severance of defendants

22.12    Waiver

Chapter 23               Double Jeopardy and Mistrial

23.01    Double jeopardy

23.02    Same offense

23.03    Lesser included offense

23.04    Dual sovereigns

23.05    The petite policy

23.06    Appeals

23.07    Collateral estoppels

23.08    Defendant’s choice

23.09    Forfeitures

23.10    Mistrial

Chapter 24               Negotiated Pleas

24.01    Overview

24.02    Plea agreements

24.03    Nolo and Alford pleas

24.04    Pleas requiring approvals

24.05    Consulting investigative agency and victim

24.06    Fraud cases

24.07    Corporations

24.08    Restitution

24.09    Plea agreements and appeal waivers

24.10    Pretrial diversion

24.11    Pretrial diversion – eligibility criteria

24.12    Contract principals apply

24.13    Wired & global plea agreements

24.14    Third party and monetary considerations

24.15    Asset forfeiture

24.16    Proffers, waivers, and Mezzanatto

24.17    Plea procedures

Chapter 25               Jury Issues

25.01    Overview

25.02    Waiver of right to jury trial

25.03    Waiver of right to have twelve persons on jury

25.04    Voir dire

25.05    Batson challenges

25.06    Batson: procedure after prima facie discrimination

25.07    Batson: permissible and impermissible reasons

25.08    Challenges for cause

25.09    Peremptory challenges

25.10    Sequestration of jury

25.11    Simultaneous use of two juries

25.12    Anonymous jury

25.13    Release of juror names and addresses

25.14    Replacement of juror with alternate

25.15    Substitution of alternate after deliberations have begun

25.16    Temporary disability of deliberating jurors

25.17    Communications between trial court and jury

25.18    Juror misconduct  or bias

25.19    Outside contact with jurors

25.20    Jurors seeing defendant in handcuffs

25.21    Note taking by jurors

25.22    Jury questioning of witnesses

25.23    Jury instructions

25.24    Rereading testimony

25.25    Sending exhibits to jury room

25.26    Sending indictment to jury

25.27    Deadlocked jury

25.28    Polling the jury

25.29    Unclear, partial and inconsistent verdicts

25.30    Testimony by jurors that may impeach verdict

Chapter 26               Trial Issues

26.01    Overview

26.02    Trial sequence

26.03    Role of judge

26.04    Comment on evidence

26.05    Absence of defendant

26.06    Bench conferences

26.07    Use of interpreters

26.08    Excluding witnesses

26.09    Attorney conferring w/defendant

26.10    Stipulations

26.11    Recalcitrant witness

26.12    Evasive/equivocal answers

26.13    Disruptive defendant

26.14    Courtroom experiments

26.15    Chain of custody

26.16    Mistrial

26.17    Rule 29 motions for judgment of acquittal

26.18    Reopening after resting

26.19    Prosecution concepts

26.20    Successive  cross-examination

26.21    Rebuttal

Chapter 27               Common Defenses

27.01    Overview

27.02    Culpable mental state defenses – generally

27.03    Culpable mental defenses – drug cases

27.04    Intent to distribute

27.05    Good faith defense

27.06    Good faith instruction

27.07    Advice of counsel defense

27.08    Advice of counsel instruction

27.09    Willful blindness

27.10    Insanity

27.11    Insanity – scoop of expert testimony

27.12    Insanity – jury instruction

27.13    Insanity – special verdict and commitment

27.14    Mental competency to stand trial distinguished

27.15    Diminished capacity

27.16    Entrapment – generally

27.17    Entrapment as a matter of law

27.18    Derivative entrapment

27.19    Outrageous government conduct

27.20    Public authority

27.21    Entrapment by estopple

27.22    Classified Information Procedures Act (CIPA)

27.23    The drug-addict defense

27.24    The buyer/seller defense

27.25    Duress

27.26    Alibi

27.27    Statutes of limitation defense

27.28    Self-defense

27.29    Aggression and mutual combat

27.30    Reasonable force, deadly force

27.31    Immediate or present danger

27.32    Duty to retreat

27.33    Defense of third persons

27.34    Imperfect self-defense

27.35    Battered woman syndrome

27.36    Justification and excusable homicide

27.37    Justification – choice of evils

27.38    Attempt

27.39    Lesser included offenses

Chapter 28               Sentence

28.01    Historical background

28.02    Apprendi v. New Jersey and Clakely v. Washington

28.03    The circuits’ response

28.04    The future of sentencing

Chapter 29               Post trial proceedings

29.01    Overview

29.02    Judgment of acquittal

29.03    Arrest of judgment

29.04    Motion for new trial

29.05    Correction of sentence

29.06    Substantial assistance

29.07    Appeals

29.08    Habeas corpus

29.09    2241 Petitions

29.10      2255 Petitions